Discuss the positive and negative aspects of the article (i.e., Was the purpose clear? Did the methodology make sense to you? Could the research question be approached in a better/different manner? Were inconsistencies between predictions and findings clarified effectively? Did the authors adequately identify limitations of the research?)

Summarize the article (its purpose, background, research question, methodology, and results)
Identify what the study tells us that we did not know before
Examine the implications of the article on organizations and how they operate
Explore what future research should address
Discuss the positive and negative aspects of the article (i.e., Was the purpose clear? Did the methodology make sense to you? Could the research question be approached in a better/different manner? Were inconsistencies between predictions and findings clarified effectively? Did the authors adequately identify limitations of the research?)
Your paper should conclude with a personal note of reflection discussing your reaction to this exercise and what you learned or observed about human resources research