In your opinion should either of these men have been allowed to continue in a command position? Why or why not?Discuss

(Please refer to additional materials attachment)

PROMPT: After reading Chapter 2 in Hanson, discuss the effects of combat trauma on the leadership of Union General Sherman and Confederate General Nathan Bedford Forrest.

In your opinion should either of these men have been allowed to continue in a command position?

Why or why not?

Who then should have been ultimately responsible for these officers’ post-Shiloh performance of duties and is this a microcosm of military cultures not addressing the seriousness of psychological trauma?