Was the writer careless, turning in a draft and not fixing obvious typos?

Content: Was the tone objective and critical or did it sound promotional?

Structure: Did it have a topic statement, a body that supported the thesis, and a strong conclusion?

Grammar: Was the writer careless, turning in a draft and not fixing obvious typos? Did the writer include runon sentences or sentence fragments? Did the writer capitalize and italicize what needed to be, etc.?

Research: Did the writer use appropriate sources  three sources with identifiable authors; journalists or authors rather than publicists or encyclopedias? Does the paper clearly attribute its facts?”