Do you find significant differences between the genres on this question?

Popular Culture and the Media

On the whole, is popular culture progressive or reactionary?

Explain the opposing viewpoints on this question among writers on popular culture, and set out the relevant criteria by which works of popular culture might be judged in this regard.

In framing your answer, choose four appropriate works from different genres (literature, film, television, and music), including at least one that is not American, and identify the elements in them that support your argument as well as any that run counter to it.

Do you find significant differences between the genres on this question?