Why do traditional punishments, consequences and rewards not work with students?

Chapter 4

Write a page and a half page paper including the question below

Why do traditional punishments, consequences and rewards not work with students?

Why is the appreciation so valuable? How does chapter 3 challenge some of your values regarding the discipline of students?

Book can be found at https://issuu.com/michaelpillsbury/docs/discipline_with_dignity_4th_ed._pdf