If the job of the jury is to determine what was “reasonable”, how important is the composition of the jury for making the decisions? Can we agree on a single standard for “reasonable” conduct?Discuss.

For your response, reflect on the case of Yoshi Hattori that is presented in Chapter 5. Answer the following questions:

1. What was your reaction to the case?

2. If the job of the jury is to determine what was “reasonable”, how important is the composition of the jury for making the decisions? Can we agree on a single standard for “reasonable” conduct?

3. Even though he has been acquitted by the criminal system, Rodney was found liable by the civil law system. Which verdict do you believe is more just? Do you believe that Rodney “owes” restitution to the victims family? Why or why not?